|
As the clock ticks until the electoral college meets in December
13 to finalize the 2004 presidential election, a second day of
informal hearings was held in the US Congress today on possible
fraud in that election, with Reps. Conyers, Jackson Lee, Nadler
and Watt among those in attendance.
Although Ohio and Florida were the states most often mentioned,
several speakers noted that other states were also troublingly
problematic. Discrepancies between exit polls and voting machine
tallies and unequal distribution of voting machines leading to
unprecidented long lines to vote were mentioned by several speakers,
as was the case of a female Ohio supreme court candidate who received
hundreds of thousands more votes than Kerry, especially in precincts
where she was less known.
Rev. Jesse Jackson called for voting machines to be impounded
and for the body convened to conduct hearings in Ohio. Rep. Conyers
responded that they would in fact go to Ohio. Calling Ohio's voting
a "classic calamity" and using sports analogies, Jackson asked
whether the Superbowl would be called without the benefit of referees
viewing instant replays. He called for an end to voter suppression
and marginalization and supported Congressman Jesse Jackson Jr.'s
bill for a voting rights constitutional amendment.
Ralph Neas of People
for the American Way held up a report that group published
along with the NAACP and Lawyer's Committee for Civil Rights,
saying it "shattered the myth" that 2004 was a fair election.
He called the vote a travesty and said that the 40,000 complaints
received were just the tip of the iceberg and perhaps millions
of voters were disenfranchised, mentioning Mexican Americans in
Arizona and blacks in Georgia. "Whether in the Ukraine or the
USA, every vote should be counted. the US should be a model of
democracy, not hypocrisy." Neas's group has held hearings in Ohio
and plans to do so in seven other states.
Green Party presidential candidate David Cobb made a case for
recognizing third party attempts to get a recount, noting that
ballot access is easier in the countries of the former USSR than
in many US states, and most other democracies have proportional
representation and instant run-off voting, empowering citizens
to better participate in elections. He noted than many reforms
in this country including the abolition of slavery, women's right
to vote, the creation of the Social Security administration were
first championed by third parties. He called for publicly funded
elections and supported Congressman Jackson's right to vote bill.
Attorney Cliff Arnebeck of Alliance for Democracy and Common
Cause Ohio said, "The fraud in this election in Ohio must be fixed
before this election is finalized. ...We will not move on until
we find out what the fraud was and correct it." Saying that the
recent elections in the Ukraine were a pertinent analogy to ours,
he asked how the US could, "with a straight face," help establish
free elections in Iraq in January with the record of a corrupt
election in this county. He pointed out that the news media determined
Al Gore won Florida in the 2000 election and said, "We should
never again certify and inaugurate a candidate until we've established
that they've got the most votes."
Stephen Rosenfeld, producer of the Laura Flanders show on Air
America radio network, called the tactics in Ohio "old school
thuggery combined with new school manipulations." The old school
was shorting machines in Democratic districts and the new was
possible electronic maniupulation. Noting that Air America's audience
had helped raise money for the Ohio recount, he called for a nonpartisan
analysis. Professor Robert Fitrakis, editor of the Free Press,
said there was a 74% loss of voting machines in heavily Democratic
districts and no loss in heavily Republican districts. Eleanor
Smeal of the Feminist Majority
highlighted the long lines seen at colleges in Ohio and said in
the future her group would count the number of voting machines
and fight for more machines where needed. Smeal also said voter
registration numbers and voter purging should be looked at, She
said an analysis of the "treemendous variance between electronic
equipment, OCR, and punch cards" was available on her group's
website.
Stephen Freeman of the University of Pennsylvania published
a paper detailing the statistical impossibility of the discrepancy
between exit polls and voting results. He said, however, he was
hampered by unreleased data and said that current data has been
adjusted by the polling companies assuming the vote was correct.
Sawnta Walcott of Zogby International polling called for a blue
ribbon, bi-partisan panel to examine the "uncharacteristically
inaccurate" exit polling.
Jon Greenbaum of the Lawyer's Committee for Civil Rights Voting
Rights Project, said, "Across the nation, we saw state and partisan
election officials, priveleging their party's success, and sometimes
their own personal political ambition, over the rights of their
constituency. These cracks in our infrastructure need to be addressed,
not just in Ohio, but elsewhere as well." He called upon the "unprecedented"
number of activist citizens and policymakers not to let the moment
pass without action. After encountering long lines at their voting
place, Ohio state Senator Rev. William Moss announced he and his
wife are the lead plaintiffs in a lawsuit to be filed tomorrow
petitioning judgment against Blackwell for conflict of interest
and a deliberate failure to supply the necessary number of voting
machines to ensure voters' rights.
John Bonifaz of National Voting
Rights Institute (Boston), who serves as co-counsel for Cobb
and Libertarian party candidate Michael Badnerick in their call
for a recount in Ohio, accused Blackwell of obstructing the recount
process, stalling for time until the vote is certified by the
electoral college. Bonifaz said that there is a chance that a
different set of electors will meet and cast their vote for president
in Ohio presenting their results to the US Congress on Jan. 6,
2005, when they meet. "We will have a recount, and the fight
will go on," he said.
|